Antimicrobial resistance
(AMR) is recognized as one of the most pressing global health challenges,
responsible for increasing morbidity, mortality, and healthcare costs worldwide
(1). The rapid emergence of multidrug-resistant
pathogens has significantly reduced the effectiveness of conventional
antibiotics, necessitating the search for novel antimicrobial materials. In this
context, inorganic nanomaterials, especially transition-metal molybdates, have
gained considerable attention due to their multifunctional roles in
photocatalysis, luminescence, and antimicrobial activity (2)
The ternary
transition-metal molybdate compound zinc molybdate (ZnMoO₄) has garnered a lot
of attention lately because of its combination of special chemical and physical
characteristics, such as chemical stability, biocidal activity, and
photocatalytic behavior. Because molybdate-based materials may produce reactive
oxygen species (ROS), which damage microbial membranes and prevent the
development of harmful bacteria and other microbes, they are generally regarded
as potential antibacterial agents.(3). One of the most researched ternary oxides in the
AMoO4 family is zinc molybdate (A is a transition element or a
divalent metal from the alkaline earth column). It comes in two different
crystallographic forms: β-ZnMoO4, which is monoclinic with both zinc
and molybdenum in octahedral geometry, and α-ZnMoO4, which has a
triclinic cell with zinc in an octahedral site and molybdenum in a tetrahedral
site. ZnMoO4 is less hazardous since it is insoluble in water. It
serves as a white pigment.
Photocatalysis, phosphor
for light-emitting diodes, electrochemical anode material for lithium
batteries, scintillating bolometers for double beta decay of 100Mo, humidity
sensors, antibacterial, biological imaging of deep tumors, supercapacitors, and
catalysis in the oxidation of propane and propene are just a few of the many
uses for this material(4). Among molybdates, zinc molybdate (ZnMoO₄) stands out because of its chemical
stability, tunable optical properties, and inherent antimicrobial potential. Recent
studies demonstrated that nano-ZnMoO₄ particles, particularly with rod or
hybrid morphologies, exhibit strong antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus
aureus. Notably, nanosized ZnMoO₄ achieved minimum inhibitory concentration
(MIC) values as low as 10 ppm, compared to 200 ppm for bulk particles,
emphasizing the critical role of particle size and morphology in biological
efficacy (5). Furthermore, ZnMoO₄ synthesized via green or
ultrasonic methods has shown promising photocatalytic degradation of dyes and
concurrent antibacterial effects, making it a multifunctional candidate for
environmental and biomedical applications (6,7). Zinc itself is well established as an
antimicrobial agent. Zn²⁺ ions destabilize bacterial membranes, disrupt
enzymatic processes, and promote reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation,
leading to cell death (8). For instance, zinc-doped hydroxyapatite ceramics
demonstrated significant inhibitory effects against Escherichia coli and
Staphylococcus aureus, with higher Zn content directly correlating with
enhanced antimicrobial activity (9). Similarly, ZnO and ZnO-based nanostructures have
been extensively studied for their antibacterial performance, where dopants,
surface charge, and morphology critically determine their efficacy (10). These findings highlight the versatility of
zinc-containing compounds in designing effective antimicrobial agents.
Despite these positive
outcomes, ZnMoO₄'s inherent electronic structure and surface activity may
restrict its effectiveness as an antibacterial agent. Doping with rare-earth
elements like holmium (Ho) is one efficient way to increase its antibacterial
efficacy. The structural, optical, and electrical characteristics of oxide and
molybdate hosts can be changed by rare-earth dopants, which can then affect the
production of ROS and interactions with microorganisms. Doping usually modifies
charge carrier dynamics, surface imperfections, and crystallite size,
increasing the number of active sites for ROS generation and enhancing biocidal
effect. (11).
Despite these advantages, ZnMoO₄ still faces
limitations, including stability under environmental stress, possible
cytotoxicity, and limited antimicrobial efficiency under dark conditions. One
promising approach to overcome these issues is rare-earth ion doping, which has been widely used to tune
structural, electronic, and optical properties of host lattices. Rare-earth
ions can introduce defect sites, alter band gaps, and enhance surface
interactions, thereby potentially improving antimicrobial efficiency (12)(13). Holmium (Ho³⁺), a lanthanide element, has unique optical and
magnetic properties, and its incorporation into oxide matrices has been shown
to alter surface defects, band gap, and morphology. While direct reports on
holmium-doped ZnMoO₄ are scarce, related studies indicate that Ho-doped ZnO
nanostructures display modified structural and luminescent properties, suggesting
possible enhancements in antimicrobial performance through ROS generation and
surface modification (14). Moreover, rare-earth ions
in general have demonstrated antibacterial, antifungal, and antibiofilm
activities with relatively low cytotoxicity compared to heavy metals such as
copper and silver (15,16). For example,
Ho-containing bioactive glasses have shown selective cytotoxicity against
osteosarcoma cells while supporting pre-osteoblast proliferation, highlighting
biomedical safety and functional potential (17). The current study
emphasizes zinc molybdate (ZnMoO₄) as a promising antimicrobial agent due to
its chemical stability, tunable optical properties, and ability to generate
reactive oxygen species (ROS) that facilitate microbial destruction. However,
the intrinsic electronic structure, limited surface activity, and diminished
performance under dark conditions restrict the efficacy of pristine ZnMoO₄. To
overcome these limitations, rare-earth ion doping has emerged as an effective
modification approach. Specifically, introducing holmium (Ho³⁺) ions into the
ZnMoO₄ lattice can alter its crystal framework, create defect sites, tailor the
band gap, and enhance charge carrier dynamics, thereby boosting ROS production
and antimicrobial potency. While direct studies on Ho-doped ZnMoO₄ remain
scarce, evidence from related rare-earth-doped oxide systems indicates strong
potential for improved antimicrobial activity with favorable biocompatibility.
Building on this, the present work undertakes the synthesis of Ho-doped ZnMoO₄
and a detailed investigation of its structural, optical, and morphological
characteristics, alongside its antimicrobial effectiveness against clinically
significant bacterial strains. This research seeks to address existing
knowledge gaps and advance the development of multifunctional antimicrobial
materials for biomedical and environmental applications.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1
Material
The Ho-doped
ZnMoO4 nanomaterial was synthesized using high-purity reagents to
ensure reliable results. Zinc sulphate heptahydrate (ZnSO4⋅7H2O)
and sodium molybdate dihydrate (Na2MoO4⋅2H2O),
both 99.8% pure and sourced from
Merck, served as zinc and molybdenum precursors. Holmium nitrate hexahydrate (Ho(NO3)3⋅6H2O)
with 99.99% purity was used as
the dopant to incorporate Ho ions into the ZnMoO4 lattice.
Acetone and
ethylene glycol (Merck) were used as solvents and reaction media to ensure
uniform mixing and controlled nanomaterial growth. Urea (HiMedia) served as a
precipitating and complexing agent, regulating nucleation and particle
development. Methylene blue dye (S.D. Fine) was employed as a model organic
pollutant in photocatalytic activity studies.
For antibacterial studies, pure
cultures of Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus were used as
representative Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacterial strains, respectively.
Natural agar media obtained from Hi-Media were used for bacterial culturing and
antimicrobial assays.
|
Bacterial
Species
|
Concentration
of HoZnMoO4 nano material
|
|
10 µg/mL
|
20 µg/mL
|
30 µg/mL
|
|
E. coli
|
0.8 mm
|
1.5 mm
|
3.7 mm
|
|
S. aureus
|
0.0 mm
|
0.2 mm
|
0.8
mm
|
All chemicals used were of
analytical grade, purchased commercially, and applied without further
purification to preserve their properties. Triply distilled water, prepared in
an all-glass apparatus, was used throughout to remove ionic and organic
impurities, ensuring a pure reaction medium and reliable experimental results.
2.2 Antibacterial Activity
Overall, two E. coli (gram
negative) and S. aureus (gram positive), were analysed to show
antibacterial activity of ZnMoO4based nano
material. The strains were already
isolated from patients with urinary
tract infections and sewage water. Antibacterial activity was well diffused
assay on nutrient agar medium (NAM), which put into Petri dish under sterile
conditions and kept it up to 1 h for solidification. After that, fresh cultured
E. coli and S. aureus (100
µg/mL) used in two different agar media. Both used media left for 15–20 min for
complete absorption. Wells were prepared by gel puncture (7–8 mm) under aseptic
conditions. At different concentration (10, 20, and 30 µg/mL), samples of HoZnMoO4, nano material added into wells.
Those treated dishes with nano materials kept up to 30 min at room temperature
and allow the diffusion of extracts. After that incubated it at 37
up to 24 h for
maximum growth of micro-organisms. Nano materials with antibacterial activity
showed inhibition of microorganism growth via clear zone of inhibition (ZOI)
around the well after incubation.
3
Result and Discussion
3.1 Antibacterial
Activities
The
antibacterial property of Ho doped ZnMoO4 nano material, prevented
the further growth of two bacterial strains like E. coli and S.
aureus. It was processed as inhibiting protein synthesis (18).
According
to Fig 1, showed that the different ZOI (zones of inhibition) for antibacterial
activity obtained through holmium doped zinc molybdate (Ho-ZnMoO4)
with different concentrations (10, 20 and 30 µg/mL) in methanol (Table 1).
Here,
it was clearly showed that HoZnMoO4 nano material produced quite better ZOI for E.
coli then S. aureus (Fig 1). S. aureuspoorly showed ZOI (Fig
1). Where, E. coli showed small clear area around sample, showed
complete inhibition. The space surrounded with ZOI, which called partial zone
of inhibition, where smaller activity observed.
Table 1: Zones of
inhibition (ZOIs) of antimicrobial activity for Ho-ZnMoO4
nano material (10, 20, and 30 µg/mL) with different concentrations in
methanol solvent
Figure
1: (a) E. coli; (b) S. aureus treated with
Ho-ZnMoO4 nano material in different concentration in methanol (10,
20 and 30 µg/mL).
4.
Conclusion
The present study demonstrated the successful
synthesis and evaluation of holmium-doped zinc molybdate (Ho–ZnMoO4)
nanomaterials for their antimicrobial activity. Antimicrobial resistance
continues to pose a critical global challenge, and the development of
multifunctional nanomaterials provides a promising alternative to conventional
antibiotics. In this work, Ho–ZnMoO4 exhibited significant
inhibitory effects against both Gram-negative (Escherichia coli) and
Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus) bacterial strains, with
performance strongly influenced by concentration. The nanomaterial produced
notable zones of inhibition (ZOIs) against E. coli, achieving a maximum
of 3.7 mm at 30 µg/mL, while S. aureus showed comparatively weaker
inhibition, reaching 0.8 mm at the same concentration. These results highlight
the greater susceptibility of Gram-negative bacteria to the synthesized
material, likely due to differences in cell wall structure and surface
interactions. The findings also underscore the role of holmium doping in
enhancing the antibacterial performance of ZnMoO4, possibly through
defect engineering, reactive oxygen species generation, and improved surface
reactivity. Overall, Ho–ZnMoO4 emerges as a promising nanomaterial
for antimicrobial applications, particularly for targeting Gram-negative
pathogens. Future studies should further investigate its cytotoxicity,
mechanism of action, and potential incorporation into biomedical and
environmental systems.